
Do Non-Collision Claims Affect Insurance
Non-collision claims usually count against you too, just often less than an at-fault crash does.
Free to compare

A deer strike after you retired
You're driving home at dusk on a rural road you now take more often since retiring, and a deer runs into your path. You can't avoid it, the front end is damaged, and you file a comprehensive claim because this is exactly what that coverage is for. The repair gets approved quickly and you're back on the road within a couple weeks.
At renewal, you notice your premium went up slightly even though the claim wasn't your fault in any legal sense. You call your agent to ask why, and they explain that comprehensive claims still factor into how the insurer sees your overall risk, especially if you've had more than one in recent years. You ask whether moving to a different insurer might undo that bump, and you start comparing quotes to find out. In the end you stay put because your long tenure with that insurer offsets the small increase, but you now check your policy each year instead of assuming it will renew the same way.
Will a non-collision claim stop me from getting a good rate later?
One claim, especially a smaller one, rarely locks you out of good rates for long. Insurers look at patterns more than single events, so a single weather or glass claim years ago matters far less than two or three comprehensive claims in a short stretch.
What matters more going forward is how you shop. Insurers weigh claim history differently from each other, so the company that penalized you lightly for a windshield claim might weigh a theft claim more heavily, and vice versa. If a non-collision claim bumped your rate, that's exactly the moment to compare quotes rather than assume every insurer will treat it the same way.

The claim already happened. What changes your rate now is how insurers compare it, so that's what to check.
Compare quotes now so you know whether your non-collision claim is costing you more than it should.

Should you file that non-collision claim at all
If you do
Your car gets repaired without you paying out of pocket beyond the deductible. The claim goes on your record and may raise your premium some at renewal, especially if you've had other claims recently. You keep your savings intact instead of draining them on repairs.
If you don't
You pay for the repair yourself and your claim history stays clean. Your rate likely won't move at renewal because of this incident. But you've spent money you didn't have to, and if the damage was large, that trade often isn't worth it.
Does a windshield claim count the same as a theft claim for insurance purposes?
No, insurers often treat them differently because glass claims are common and cheap to resolve, while theft claims involve bigger payouts and signal different risk. Check your policy or ask your agent how your specific insurer categorizes claim types, since this varies by company, not by state.
How long does a non-collision claim stay on my record?
It typically stays visible to insurers for several years, though the exact length varies by insurer and by state. Ask your current insurer directly how long they look back, and check this when comparing quotes since a new insurer may weigh older claims less.
Will filing a non-collision claim cost me any discounts I already have?
It can, since some discounts depend on a claim-free period and a new claim resets that clock. Check your declarations page or ask your agent which discounts you currently have and whether they're tied to claims history, because losing one can matter more than the rate increase itself.



