A winding road flanked by autumn trees leads toward a low sun setting on the horizon.

Renting Cars on Vacation

Your own policy likely covers a rented car the same way it covers your car at home, but confirm that before you drive off the lot.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Close-up of a tire tread with a nail head embedded in the rubber between grooves.

Check these before you say yes or no at the counter

  • Call your insurer first Ask directly whether your policy extends liability, collision and comprehensive coverage to a rental car. Get the answer in plain terms before you travel, not while standing at the counter.
  • Know what follows the car Most personal auto coverage follows you into a rental car rather than staying with your own vehicle. Confirm this applies to your policy and to the state or country where you're renting.
  • Credit card coverage has gaps Some credit cards offer secondary rental coverage, but it usually only kicks in after your own policy pays first. Read the card's terms so you know what it actually adds.
  • Decide on the deductible If your policy has a deductible, that amount still applies to a rental car claim. Decide if you want to pay extra at the counter to avoid owing that amount out of pocket.
  • Check coverage abroad Personal auto policies often stop covering you once you leave the country. Check this specifically if your vacation is abroad, since the counter's coverage may be your only option there.
Close-up of a car's front wheel with a ten-spoke two-tone alloy rim, five lug nuts, visible brake disc and caliper, and low-profile tire, on pavement.

A week-long trip where the coverage question actually came up

A retired couple planned a week in another state to see their grandchildren and rented a car at the airport. Before leaving home, they called their insurer and asked plainly whether their policy would cover the rental the same way it covered their own car. The agent confirmed that liability, collision and comprehensive coverage would extend to the rental, and that their existing deductible would apply if anything happened.

At the counter, the clerk offered additional coverage for an extra daily cost. Because they already knew their policy applied, they declined it and showed their insurance card when asked. Partway through the trip, another driver backed into the rental in a parking lot. They filed a claim through their own insurer, paid their usual deductible, and the rest was handled as it would have been with their own car. Knowing the answer ahead of time saved them money at the counter and kept the claim simple.

Partial view of the front right side of a dark grey car with an alloy wheel, shown against a plain white background.

The real risk isn't the rental car, it's assuming your coverage follows you without checking first.

Once you know how your policy treats a rental car, compare quotes to make sure that protection is priced right.

A snow-covered road curves between dense stands of snow-laden spruce trees under an overcast white sky.

Deciding whether to buy the counter's rental coverage

If you do

You pay extra each day of the rental, but you avoid touching your own deductible or filing a claim through your insurer if something happens. This can matter if you'd rather not risk your rates or paperwork over a dented bumper in an unfamiliar place.

If you don't

You rely on your own policy and whatever your credit card may add. If there's an accident, your usual deductible applies and a claim goes on your record the same as it would with your own car, which is fine if you already confirmed your coverage extends to rentals.

Does declining the rental coverage affect my regular car insurance rates?

It can, if you end up filing a claim through your own policy for an accident in the rental car. Your insurer treats that claim the same way it would treat one involving your own vehicle, and depending on your insurer's rules, it may affect your rate at renewal the same way any other claim would.

This is part of why some retirees choose to pay for the counter's coverage even when their own policy would technically cover the rental. It shifts the risk away from their own claims history entirely. Before your trip, ask your insurer directly how a rental car claim would be treated and whether it carries the same weight as a claim involving your own car. That answer, more than the daily cost at the counter, should guide your decision.

A curving two-lane coastal highway with a metal guardrail along the ocean side and a dark car driving away in the distance, with a hillside at right and a mostly clear sky.

More articles